Skip to main content

Emily Toffelmire

College Admissions Consultant She/Her/Hers
Emily Toffelmire
College Admissions Consultant
Former admissions officer at University of Southern California
Guidance and College Counselor La Cañada High School (CA)
Guidance and College Counselor The American School of Bangkok
Guidance and College Counselor Coronado High School (NV)

My Background

I came to College Coach after working for many years in college admissions and high school counseling. As a school counselor, I assisted students in the college application process and wrote hundreds of letters of recommendation, while also helping them and their families cope with any emotional, social, and academic concerns throughout the year. I transitioned from the high school setting to the admissions office when I joined the University of Southern California as an assistant director, reading freshmen and transfer applications and collaborating on admission decisions for over 150 majors, including the liberal arts, engineering, business, cinema, and the fine and performing arts. I subsequently took on the role of senior assistant director in the USC Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences, where I coordinated the division's Mork, Stamps, Trustee, Presidential and Dean's merit scholarship selection process, as well as recruitment publications and outreach, and traveled everywhere from Honolulu to Miami presenting to and interviewing hundreds of applicants each year.
Emily Toffelmire exceeded excellent. Supportive, well informed and there for both me and my son. Her sense of humor is a huge bonus as well.
Parent of a Tulane University student

Why I Joined College Coach

Though I was able to meaningfully engage with countless students and families as an admissions officer, I missed the deeper bonds that I forged with students in my high school counseling days. As I found myself climbing the ladder in admissions, I realized the prospect of less face-time with applicants and more face-time with administrators (not to mention Excel worksheets) didn’t appeal to me. College Coach struck me as the perfect place to return to my counseling roots while drawing on the admissions expertise I picked up at USC. I find it especially rewarding to build an easy rapport with students and families through open and honest communication. This gives us all a clearer sense of who the student is and what they want, and this understanding leads to a stronger, more authentic application.

Get to Know Me

My Education

University of Arkansas Bachelor's in Advertising/Public Relations
University of Nevada, Las Vegas Master's in Educational Counseling
I have worked with students interested in:
  • Accelerated medical - BS/MD
  • Business
  • Communication
  • Computer science
  • Economics
  • Engineering
  • Film
  • Graduate programs
  • HBCUs
  • Honors programs
  • Humanities
  • Ivy league
  • Large State Schools
  • Mathematics
  • Nursing
  • Physical therapy
  • Political science
  • Pre-dentistry
  • Pre-law
  • Pre-med
  • Pre-veterinary
  • Psychology
  • Religiously affiliated schools
  • Research universities
  • Science
  • Small liberal arts colleges
  • Social Sciences
  • Teaching/education certification
  • Technology
  • Theater
  • Two year colleges
  • Visual and performing arts
I have also worked with:
  • First-generation students
  • Home schooled students
  • IB program
  • International students
  • LGBTQIA+ students
  • Students with learning differences
  • Transfer students
Emily Toffelmire

Some of my favorite pastimes

Reading, checking out art museums, photography, film, trying out as many restaurants as fiscally possible, attempting to be a better cook

Learn more about other College Coach admission consultants including Gabbi Tobias today!


Interested in learning more about how our college admissions counseling services can help your student succeed?

Call 877-402-6224 or complete the form for information on getting your student started with one of our experts.

Inclusion Matters Here Pride Flag